That seems like weaseling out of the evidence to me. This is just another instance of neural networks being able to learn to do geometric computation to produce hard-edged answers, like alphago is; that they’re being used to generate programs seems not super relevant to that. I certainly agree that it’s not obvious exactly how to get them to learn the space of programs efficiently, but it seems surprising to expect it to be different in kind vs previous neural network stuff. This doesn’t seem that different to me vs attention models in terms of what kind of problem learning the internal behavior presents.
That seems like weaseling out of the evidence to me. This is just another instance of neural networks being able to learn to do geometric computation to produce hard-edged answers, like alphago is; that they’re being used to generate programs seems not super relevant to that. I certainly agree that it’s not obvious exactly how to get them to learn the space of programs efficiently, but it seems surprising to expect it to be different in kind vs previous neural network stuff. This doesn’t seem that different to me vs attention models in terms of what kind of problem learning the internal behavior presents.