I also edit my previous comments a lot after I realize there was more I ought to have said. Very bad habit—look back at the comment you just replied to please, I edited it before realizing you’d already read it! I really need to stop doing that...
Oh it’s fine, plenty of people edit their comments after posting including me, I should be mindful of that by not replying immediately :-P As for the rest of your comment:
I think your comment has a slight resemblance to Vanessa Kosoy’s “Hippocratic Timeline-Driven Learning” (Section 4.1 here), if you haven’t already heard of that.
My suspicion is that, if one were to sort out all the details, including things like the AI-human communication protocol, such that it really works and is powerful and has no failure modes, you would wind up with something that’s at least “rather messy” (again, “rather messy” means “in the same messiness ballpark as Stuart Armstrong research agenda v0.9”) (and “powerful” rules out literal Hippocratic Timeline-Driven Learning, IMO).
Gotcha, thanks :) [ETA—this was in response to just the first paragraph]
I also edit my previous comments a lot after I realize there was more I ought to have said. Very bad habit—look back at the comment you just replied to please, I edited it before realizing you’d already read it! I really need to stop doing that...
Oh it’s fine, plenty of people edit their comments after posting including me, I should be mindful of that by not replying immediately :-P As for the rest of your comment:
I think your comment has a slight resemblance to Vanessa Kosoy’s “Hippocratic Timeline-Driven Learning” (Section 4.1 here), if you haven’t already heard of that.
My suspicion is that, if one were to sort out all the details, including things like the AI-human communication protocol, such that it really works and is powerful and has no failure modes, you would wind up with something that’s at least “rather messy” (again, “rather messy” means “in the same messiness ballpark as Stuart Armstrong research agenda v0.9”) (and “powerful” rules out literal Hippocratic Timeline-Driven Learning, IMO).