What does “plied her with alcohol” mean? Does it mean that Shermer spiked her drink or force fed her alcohol? Most likely she was drinking with him had a little too much to drink when up to his hotel room, had sex with him, in the morning regretted it and decided to declare it non-consensual.
Calling an encounter like the above “rape” is precisely what I’m objecting too.
Don’t we have a cultural tradition of privileging the hypothesis that makes someone innocent? I mean, I see people say “innocent until proven guilty” is just for the courtroom, but that strikes me as the same sort of thing as “it’s only censorship if the government does it”.
Yeah, this is a problem. It is possible that such a situation is only retroactively declared to be non-consensual, but that’s not what he’s being accused of. He’s being accused of it actually being non-consensual. Do you agree that non-consensual sex with a severely inebriated individual is rape? Because that’s the central accusation here.
What does “plied her with alcohol” mean? Does it mean that Shermer spiked her drink or force fed her alcohol? Most likely she was drinking with him had a little too much to drink when up to his hotel room, had sex with him, in the morning regretted it and decided to declare it non-consensual.
Calling an encounter like the above “rape” is precisely what I’m objecting too.
Maybe it’s as you describe, and maybe he was ignoring her saying no repeatedly. Why privilege only the hypothesis that makes Shermer innocent?
Also, the other accusations, while short of rape, are of bad behavior. Would you trust an ethicist who went around hitting people?
Don’t we have a cultural tradition of privileging the hypothesis that makes someone innocent? I mean, I see people say “innocent until proven guilty” is just for the courtroom, but that strikes me as the same sort of thing as “it’s only censorship if the government does it”.
Yeah, this is a problem. It is possible that such a situation is only retroactively declared to be non-consensual, but that’s not what he’s being accused of. He’s being accused of it actually being non-consensual. Do you agree that non-consensual sex with a severely inebriated individual is rape? Because that’s the central accusation here.