The subtle ambiguity here is between two meanings of “is fixed”:
going from a state of being unfixed to a state of being fixed
being in a state of being fixed
I think you were are interpreting me to mean 1. I only meant 2, and that’s all that I need. That the future is fixed2, before I am born, is what disturbs people, regardless of when the moment of fixing1 happens (if any).
Eliezer,
The subtle ambiguity here is between two meanings of “is fixed”:
going from a state of being unfixed to a state of being fixed
being in a state of being fixed
I think you were are interpreting me to mean 1. I only meant 2, and that’s all that I need. That the future is fixed2, before I am born, is what disturbs people, regardless of when the moment of fixing1 happens (if any).
KTW