You should also help people when they are suffering and you are able.
Quite the opposite. Most suffering is self-inflicted, and as such is a reminder that you need to learn a lesson. External help removes the suffering and makes it seem as though no lesson needs to be learned. This perpetuates the cycle and leads to more suffering.
Leaving aside my usual objection to schools, one should help one’s kids do their homework.
That said, it seems like your example is chosen specifically to sound paternalistic, which seems at odds with the free-market view you’re espousing.
Most suffering is self-inflicted
I dispute that, but don’t have relevant numbers. If your friend falls and breaks his leg, is that “self-inflicted”? Is it best to bring him to the hospital, or to leave him crying on the ground so he can learn something?
If your friend falls and breaks his leg, is that “self-inflicted”? Is it best to bring him to the hospital, or to leave him crying on the ground so he can learn something?
It seems that for some countries, falling accidentally is pandemic, while other countries rationally attempt to avoid it? Isn’t this comment willfully ignoring the analogy denisbider was using?
Quite the opposite. Most suffering is self-inflicted, and as such is a reminder that you need to learn a lesson. External help removes the suffering and makes it seem as though no lesson needs to be learned. This perpetuates the cycle and leads to more suffering.
One shouldn’t do one’s kids’ homework.
Leaving aside my usual objection to schools, one should help one’s kids do their homework.
That said, it seems like your example is chosen specifically to sound paternalistic, which seems at odds with the free-market view you’re espousing.
I dispute that, but don’t have relevant numbers. If your friend falls and breaks his leg, is that “self-inflicted”? Is it best to bring him to the hospital, or to leave him crying on the ground so he can learn something?
It seems that for some countries, falling accidentally is pandemic, while other countries rationally attempt to avoid it? Isn’t this comment willfully ignoring the analogy denisbider was using?
Okay, but what if some “kids” don’t have the necessary tools to do their “homework”?