Re: predictive processing of motor control and your minor disgreement. Super interesting! Are you familar with this work from France where they seperate out the volitional from motor and proprioceptive signals by stimulating cortex in a patient? The video is mindblowing. Not sure exactly how it relates to your disagreement but it seems to be a very similar situation to what you describe.
Thanks!
I have minor disagreements with the predictive processing account of motor control.
Yeah, I think “narrative self” is closer to what I want, for things like how the thought “I am lying” relates to the thought “Alice is lying”.
I’ll take a look at Olaf Blanke and Anil Seth, thanks for the tip :)
Re: predictive processing of motor control and your minor disgreement. Super interesting! Are you familar with this work from France where they seperate out the volitional from motor and proprioceptive signals by stimulating cortex in a patient? The video is mindblowing. Not sure exactly how it relates to your disagreement but it seems to be a very similar situation to what you describe.
https://www.science.org/doi/full/10.1126/science.1169896
I can’t figure out how to download the movies but presumably they are somewhere in that article. I do remember seeing them at some point though :/
The supporting online material says the movies are at http://www.isc.cnrs.fr/sir/article/videos_desmurget.zip but it’s a dead link, and I couldn’t find it at internet archive, and I can’t be bothered to email the authors. :-/
Very interesting article though. Verrrrry interesting. Thinking hard about it.