Voted down because this is a really bad way to make a point.
On the other hand, the basic point is a good one: “they’ll learn from it” is not in general a good reason for doing things that hurt people in whatever sense.
“they’ll learn from it” is not in general a good reason for doing things that hurt people in whatever sense.
“They’ll learn from it” is most definitely a good reason for doing things that hurt people in the specific case of people trying to hurt you (and learning not to). That is why I specified zero-sum games above.
Also, beating up my son makes him tougher so that he can handle himself better in a dangerous neighborhood.
Scamming investors out of their savings makes them smarter and more discerning. They have to learn the lesson sometime, might as well be from me.
Stealing from the local 7-Eleven makes them improve their security. I’m really doing them a favor.
Not applicable. I said
So if your son picks a fight with you … beating him up makes him tougher.
Voted down because this is a really bad way to make a point.
On the other hand, the basic point is a good one: “they’ll learn from it” is not in general a good reason for doing things that hurt people in whatever sense.
“They’ll learn from it” is most definitely a good reason for doing things that hurt people in the specific case of people trying to hurt you (and learning not to). That is why I specified zero-sum games above.