I don’t think the original comment was a troll, but I also don’t think it was a helpful contribution on this post. OP specifically framed the post as their own experience, not a universal cure. Comments explaining why it won’t work for a specific person aren’t relevant.
I like comments about other users’ experiences for similar reasons why I like OP. I think maybe the ideal such comment would identify itself more clearly as an experience report, but I’d rather have the report than not.
I don’t think the original comment was a troll, but I also don’t think it was a helpful contribution on this post. OP specifically framed the post as their own experience, not a universal cure. Comments explaining why it won’t work for a specific person aren’t relevant.
I like comments about other users’ experiences for similar reasons why I like OP. I think maybe the ideal such comment would identify itself more clearly as an experience report, but I’d rather have the report than not.