I don’t claim that everyone has that intuition, which is why I said “I guess that most people would do so...” It seems that most people in these comments, at least, do prefer A.
I don’t think that an intuition of identical copy immortality and preferring scenario A are necessarily tied. In other words, people could prefer A for reasons that have nothing to do with identical copy immortality. I don’t have a clear-cut example since I am still processing the original post.
“our intuition of identical copy immortality”
Speak for yourself—I have no such intuition.
I don’t claim that everyone has that intuition, which is why I said “I guess that most people would do so...” It seems that most people in these comments, at least, do prefer A.
I don’t think that an intuition of identical copy immortality and preferring scenario A are necessarily tied. In other words, people could prefer A for reasons that have nothing to do with identical copy immortality. I don’t have a clear-cut example since I am still processing the original post.