Even better: due to relativity, realize that if you’re only considering the earth/sun system and not paying attention to other planets, you can go ahead and choose either one as your reference frame (traditionally, you pick the one you’re in). So the sun really is quickly orbiting a stationary Earth.
“the sun goes around the Earth quickly while rotating slowly” and “the Earth is rotating quickly while orbiting the sun slowly” express the same sentiment.
EDIT: Okay, you got me—you can’t rotate an inertial frame, and ‘fictitious forces’ would be detectable differently in each of those examples. But I stand by my first point.
IANAPE, but it does seem hard to ‘relativise’ being torn assunder by centrifugal forces vs rotating slowly while the sun laughs in the face of the speed of light.
I’m thinking back to those Feynman lectures. I have an incling that he said rotation could be detected if you were stuck in one of those hypothetical transport containers. Failing that, just thinking of the relevant experiment is making my right hand turn blue for some reason.
I’ll throw those two together and surmise that “who is orbitting whom” is just a matter of “who cares? Just plug in the weights and give me relative positions and a direction” but that rotation you’ve got somewhat less flexibility with.
Even better: due to relativity, realize that if you’re only considering the earth/sun system and not paying attention to other planets, you can go ahead and choose either one as your reference frame (traditionally, you pick the one you’re in). So the sun really is quickly orbiting a stationary Earth.
“the sun goes around the Earth quickly while rotating slowly” and “the Earth is rotating quickly while orbiting the sun slowly” express the same sentiment.
EDIT: Okay, you got me—you can’t rotate an inertial frame, and ‘fictitious forces’ would be detectable differently in each of those examples. But I stand by my first point.
IANAP, but this sounds wrong to me. It would feel different to be on a slowly rotating Earth than to be on a quickly rotating Earth.
IANAPE, but it does seem hard to ‘relativise’ being torn assunder by centrifugal forces vs rotating slowly while the sun laughs in the face of the speed of light.
I’m thinking back to those Feynman lectures. I have an incling that he said rotation could be detected if you were stuck in one of those hypothetical transport containers. Failing that, just thinking of the relevant experiment is making my right hand turn blue for some reason.
I’ll throw those two together and surmise that “who is orbitting whom” is just a matter of “who cares? Just plug in the weights and give me relative positions and a direction” but that rotation you’ve got somewhat less flexibility with.
Don’t they both just move in straight lines through curved space-time, or is that just another way of percieving the math?
Like Camelot, “it’s only a model”.
Yes, that’s another way of looking at it. More or less intuitive depending on the application.