“I am now too valuable to the world to ever risk my life adventuring again. Here, Girl With Three Different Immortality Powers, take my invisibility cloak—you need it more than I do.”
Nah. There are better ways to keep yourself safe than invisibility, whereas Hermione will be running around adventuring. Sure, it’s very hard to kill her, but if she needs to, say, rescue a hostage or something, that won’t necessarily be relevant.
There are better ways to keep yourself safe than invisibility,
Not many, especially for someone too young to have the raw magic for most powerful spells. When it comes to protection, having no one know you’re there is the next best thing to not being there.
Additionally, Harry’s first instinct when he realised how much personal danger he was in was to wear the Cloak 24⁄7. It seems odd that this instinct is 100% absent now that his survival also represents the survival of the entire world.
The best way to keep yourself safe, now that Hogwarts no longer has literally Lord Voldemort in it, is to sit in the tallest tower of Hogwarts and never leave. Anyone that manages to get past the wards is not going to be stopped by the Cloak, Hallow or not.
I don’t think that’s realistic. Harry’s acknowledged that he needs to mature into a worthwhile adult in order to be able to save the world, and he’s not going to gain the experiences he needs to do that (or indeed maintain a reasonable standard of mental health) by becoming a full-on hikikomori.
It’s also worth noting that now that Lord Voldemort is gone, with Mad-Eye Moody, Amelia Bones, and the Hogwarts professors at his side, there is very little that can threaten Harry unless he goes actively looking for it (which, naturally, he will not). The Invisibility Cloak is useful, but it’s not the be-all-end-all of protection, and letting it sit in his possession when Hermione could use it to do heroic things is a rather large opportunity cost.
It’s still one ring of safety less. If the story didn’t require a “passing the torch” moment, I wouldn’t have predicted that to happen; though I might see Harry loaning the cloak for sufficiently important missions.
Belated note: Hermione had many protections against dying in Azkaban, but people were saying the Dementors might be a way to neutralize someone who has Horcruxes. The Cloak could give her an added layer of protection. Assuming Hermione figures out the True Patronus at all, it would be very odd if she didn’t think of this.
“I am now too valuable to the world to ever risk my life adventuring again. Here, Girl With Three Different Immortality Powers, take my invisibility cloak—you need it more than I do.”
Am I the only one who finds this act odd?
Nah. There are better ways to keep yourself safe than invisibility, whereas Hermione will be running around adventuring. Sure, it’s very hard to kill her, but if she needs to, say, rescue a hostage or something, that won’t necessarily be relevant.
Not many, especially for someone too young to have the raw magic for most powerful spells. When it comes to protection, having no one know you’re there is the next best thing to not being there.
Additionally, Harry’s first instinct when he realised how much personal danger he was in was to wear the Cloak 24⁄7. It seems odd that this instinct is 100% absent now that his survival also represents the survival of the entire world.
On the contrary.
The best way to keep yourself safe, now that Hogwarts no longer has literally Lord Voldemort in it, is to sit in the tallest tower of Hogwarts and never leave. Anyone that manages to get past the wards is not going to be stopped by the Cloak, Hallow or not.
I don’t think that’s realistic. Harry’s acknowledged that he needs to mature into a worthwhile adult in order to be able to save the world, and he’s not going to gain the experiences he needs to do that (or indeed maintain a reasonable standard of mental health) by becoming a full-on hikikomori.
As dxu notes, Hermione is likely to use it more than he is. And if Harry does go out, he’ll do it with Hermione, and can borrow her Cloak.
It’s not “Harry will never use the Cloak again”, it’s “it’s Hermione’s now because she’ll get the most use out of it.”
It’s also worth noting that now that Lord Voldemort is gone, with Mad-Eye Moody, Amelia Bones, and the Hogwarts professors at his side, there is very little that can threaten Harry unless he goes actively looking for it (which, naturally, he will not). The Invisibility Cloak is useful, but it’s not the be-all-end-all of protection, and letting it sit in his possession when Hermione could use it to do heroic things is a rather large opportunity cost.
It’s still one ring of safety less. If the story didn’t require a “passing the torch” moment, I wouldn’t have predicted that to happen; though I might see Harry loaning the cloak for sufficiently important missions.
Belated note: Hermione had many protections against dying in Azkaban, but people were saying the Dementors might be a way to neutralize someone who has Horcruxes. The Cloak could give her an added layer of protection. Assuming Hermione figures out the True Patronus at all, it would be very odd if she didn’t think of this.