Let me make it clear that I’m not against venting, being angry, even saying to some people “dude, we’re going to die”, all that. Eliezer has put his whole life into this field and I don’t think it’s fair to say he shouldn’t be angry from time to time. It’s also not a good idea to pretend things are better than they actually are, and that includes regulating your emotional state to the point that you can’t accurately convey things. But if the linchpin of LessWrong says that the field is being drowned by idiots pushing low-quality ideas (in so many words), then we shouldn’t be surprised when even people who might have something to contribute decide to withhold those contributions, because they don’t know whether or not they’re the people doing the thing he’s explicitly critiquing.
Let me make it clear that I’m not against venting, being angry, even saying to some people “dude, we’re going to die”, all that. Eliezer has put his whole life into this field and I don’t think it’s fair to say he shouldn’t be angry from time to time. It’s also not a good idea to pretend things are better than they actually are, and that includes regulating your emotional state to the point that you can’t accurately convey things. But if the linchpin of LessWrong says that the field is being drowned by idiots pushing low-quality ideas (in so many words), then we shouldn’t be surprised when even people who might have something to contribute decide to withhold those contributions, because they don’t know whether or not they’re the people doing the thing he’s explicitly critiquing.