The problem with this scenario is that the number of people who have a deontological rule “never kill anyone with your bare hands” is zero. There are people who have a rule that can be informally described as “never kill people with your bare hands”, and which in most situations works like it, but that’s different.
If anything, most people’s rules are closer to “never kill anyone with your bare hands, except for small probabilities in a Pascal’s Mugging scenario”. If you asked them what their rules were, they’d never describe it that way, of course. Normies don’t bother being precise enough to exclude low probability scenarios.
The problem with this scenario is that the number of people who have a deontological rule “never kill anyone with your bare hands” is zero. There are people who have a rule that can be informally described as “never kill people with your bare hands”, and which in most situations works like it, but that’s different.
If anything, most people’s rules are closer to “never kill anyone with your bare hands, except for small probabilities in a Pascal’s Mugging scenario”. If you asked them what their rules were, they’d never describe it that way, of course. Normies don’t bother being precise enough to exclude low probability scenarios.