Lupin was publicly outed as the wizarding version of a leper, if every leper was considered a serial killer, and this information that will not become secret again later. If he was having trouble keeping himself employed before...
Umbridge was freaking gang-raped by centaurs, traumatizing her. I mean, she got better and did get a nice position later, but...jeez.
Snape did survive a whole extra year, that’s true, but then he died. By the hand of the same person who implemented the curse, by the by. It could be a coincidence...but maybe not.
Lupin seems to have done okay. Yeah, being outed is unpleasant, but it doesn’t seem to have really affected him.
Umbridge...well, I have difficulty believing that even Voldemort would include bestial gang-rape as part of a curse. And while it is again something I wouldn’t want to have happen(to put it lightly), she doesn’t seem the worse for wear—she’s not any crazier after than before.
The Snape angle is interesting, though—I never thought of it that way.
I assumed he kept working for Dumbledore, via the Order of the Phoenix. At the very least, after Voldemort did rise again. He certainly was being kept busy enough by them from the 5th year on.
I don’t really have this difficulty, but alright. I doubt he specified anything in the casting—it could be as simple as “they leave the position before the end of the year in a manner that makes them feel regret.” Snape would certainly regret having to kill Dumbledore.
I know, the levels of Umbridge’s trauma at the end of 5th year is inconsistent with how she was seen later. I thought that mental magics were involved, but I admit it’s speculative.
...what?
Lupin was publicly outed as the wizarding version of a leper, if every leper was considered a serial killer, and this information that will not become secret again later. If he was having trouble keeping himself employed before...
Umbridge was freaking gang-raped by centaurs, traumatizing her. I mean, she got better and did get a nice position later, but...jeez.
Snape did survive a whole extra year, that’s true, but then he died. By the hand of the same person who implemented the curse, by the by. It could be a coincidence...but maybe not.
Lupin seems to have done okay. Yeah, being outed is unpleasant, but it doesn’t seem to have really affected him.
Umbridge...well, I have difficulty believing that even Voldemort would include bestial gang-rape as part of a curse. And while it is again something I wouldn’t want to have happen(to put it lightly), she doesn’t seem the worse for wear—she’s not any crazier after than before.
The Snape angle is interesting, though—I never thought of it that way.
I assumed he kept working for Dumbledore, via the Order of the Phoenix. At the very least, after Voldemort did rise again. He certainly was being kept busy enough by them from the 5th year on.
I don’t really have this difficulty, but alright. I doubt he specified anything in the casting—it could be as simple as “they leave the position before the end of the year in a manner that makes them feel regret.” Snape would certainly regret having to kill Dumbledore.
I know, the levels of Umbridge’s trauma at the end of 5th year is inconsistent with how she was seen later. I thought that mental magics were involved, but I admit it’s speculative.