Was Mr. Hall cheating? Not according to the rules of the show, because he did have the option of not offering the switch, and he usually did not offer it.
thomblake’s remark was relevant too, though—from what I said, you might imagine that Monty Hall let people switch on the show. All the clarifications are relevant and good.
exactly as Robin said.
thomblake’s remark was relevant too, though—from what I said, you might imagine that Monty Hall let people switch on the show. All the clarifications are relevant and good.
Yes, you might imagine that, and you’d probably be right. Thom’s quote is evidence against that claim, but very weak.