To the extent that you’re saying that the whole topic of Christian/queer relations was inappropriate for an intro thread, I would prefer you’d just said that. I might even agree with you, though I didn’t find paper-machine’s initial comment especially problematic.
To the extent that you’re saying that paper-machine should not treat the prior poor treatment of members of a group they belong to, by members of a group Y belongs to, as evidence of their likely poor treatment by Y, I simply disagree. It may not be especially strong evidence, but it’s also far from trivial.
And all the stuff about martyrdom and Parties of Suffering and who gets to say what for whom seems like a complete distraction.
To the extent that you’re saying that the whole topic of Christian/queer relations was inappropriate for an intro thread, I would prefer you’d just said that. I might even agree with you, though I didn’t find paper-machine’s initial comment especially problematic.
To the extent that you’re saying that paper-machine should not treat the prior poor treatment of members of a group they belong to, by members of a group Y belongs to, as evidence of their likely poor treatment by Y, I simply disagree. It may not be especially strong evidence, but it’s also far from trivial.
And all the stuff about martyrdom and Parties of Suffering and who gets to say what for whom seems like a complete distraction.