For my own part, I think you’re treating “being nice” and “liking the Christian God” and “hating Christians” and “wanting other people to hate God” and “only wanting other people to hate God” and “forcibly exterminating all morality” and various other things as much more tightly integrated concepts than they actually are, and it’s interfering with your predictions.
So I suggest separating those concepts more firmly in your own mind.
For my own part, I think you’re treating “being nice” and “liking the Christian God” and “hating Christians” and “wanting other people to hate God” and “only wanting other people to hate God” and “forcibly exterminating all morality” and various other things as much more tightly integrated concepts than they actually are, and it’s interfering with your predictions.
So I suggest separating those concepts more firmly in your own mind.
Sort of related: The Two-Party Swindle and the concept of belief-as-identity.