Well, theology isn’t science. If you do an experiment and the result goes against your hypothesis, your hypothosis is false, period. It’s not necissarily like that when people are arguing with logic instead of experiments. No one on either side would make an argument that wasn’t logically correct. I’ve read both Christian and Atheist material that make a lot of sense sense, although I realize now that I should probably review them because that was before I discovered Less Wrong. There are also plenty of intelligent people who have looked at all the evidence and gone both ways.
There is something very wrong here, from a rationalist’s point of view.
Are there people here that have gone from Christianity to Atheism or the other way around? Or for any other religion? Can I talk to you?
There is something very wrong here, from a rationalist’s point of view.
Seems to me the wrong thing is exactly that experiments are not allowed in the debate. Leaving out the voice of reality, all we are left with are the voices of humans. And humans are well known liars.
Well, theology isn’t science. If you do an experiment and the result goes against your hypothesis, your hypothosis is false, period. It’s not necissarily like that when people are arguing with logic instead of experiments. No one on either side would make an argument that wasn’t logically correct. I’ve read both Christian and Atheist material that make a lot of sense sense, although I realize now that I should probably review them because that was before I discovered Less Wrong. There are also plenty of intelligent people who have looked at all the evidence and gone both ways.
There is something very wrong here, from a rationalist’s point of view.
Are there people here that have gone from Christianity to Atheism or the other way around? Or for any other religion? Can I talk to you?
Seems to me the wrong thing is exactly that experiments are not allowed in the debate. Leaving out the voice of reality, all we are left with are the voices of humans. And humans are well known liars.
The trouble with trying to run experiments to prove the existence of God is that it’s very, very difficult to catch out a reclusive omniscient being.