I should qualify this statement: “As such, we shouldn’t expect much more moral agreement from humans than from rational (or approximately rational) AIs.”
to instead read:
“As such, on ethical questions that had no precedent in our EEA, we shouldn’t expect much more moral agreement from humans than from rational (or approximately rational) AIs, apart, of course, from the fact that most humans share a common set of cognitive biases”
one can see that this is true by looking at the vast disagreements between different moral philosophers consequentialists vs. deontological ethicists, or atheists vs. christians vs. muslims, or libertarians vs. liberals vs. communists.
I should qualify this statement: “As such, we shouldn’t expect much more moral agreement from humans than from rational (or approximately rational) AIs.”
to instead read:
“As such, on ethical questions that had no precedent in our EEA, we shouldn’t expect much more moral agreement from humans than from rational (or approximately rational) AIs, apart, of course, from the fact that most humans share a common set of cognitive biases”
one can see that this is true by looking at the vast disagreements between different moral philosophers consequentialists vs. deontological ethicists, or atheists vs. christians vs. muslims, or libertarians vs. liberals vs. communists.