Interesting. I guess the right question is, if you insist on a frequentist argument, how simple can you make it? Like I said, I don’t expect things like unbiased estimates to behave intuitively. Can you make the argument about long run frequencies only? That would go a long way in convincing me that you found a genuine contradiction.
Yes, I have given a long run frequency argument for halving in part I. Sadly that part have not gotten any attention. My entire argument is about the importance of perspective disagreement in SBP. This counter argument is actually the less important part.
Interesting. I guess the right question is, if you insist on a frequentist argument, how simple can you make it? Like I said, I don’t expect things like unbiased estimates to behave intuitively. Can you make the argument about long run frequencies only? That would go a long way in convincing me that you found a genuine contradiction.
Yes, I have given a long run frequency argument for halving in part I. Sadly that part have not gotten any attention. My entire argument is about the importance of perspective disagreement in SBP. This counter argument is actually the less important part.