I can in fact imagine what else a super-intelligence would use instead of a goal system. A bunch of different ones even. For example, a lump of incomprehensible super-solomonoff-compressed code that approximates a hypercomputer simulating a multiverse with the utility function as an epiphenomenal physical law feeding backwards in time to the AIs actions. Or a carefully tuned decentralized process (think natural selection, or the invisible hand) found to match the AIs previous goals exactly by searching through an infinite platonic space.
(yes, half of those are not real words; the goal was to imagine something that per definition could not be understood, so it’s hard to do better than vaguely pointing in the direction of a feeling.)
Edit: I forgot: “goal system replaced by completely arbitrary thing that resembles it even less because it was traded away counterfactually to another part of tegmark-5”
I can in fact imagine what else a super-intelligence would use instead of a goal system. A bunch of different ones even. For example, a lump of incomprehensible super-solomonoff-compressed code that approximates a hypercomputer simulating a multiverse with the utility function as an epiphenomenal physical law feeding backwards in time to the AIs actions. Or a carefully tuned decentralized process (think natural selection, or the invisible hand) found to match the AIs previous goals exactly by searching through an infinite platonic space.
(yes, half of those are not real words; the goal was to imagine something that per definition could not be understood, so it’s hard to do better than vaguely pointing in the direction of a feeling.)
Edit: I forgot: “goal system replaced by completely arbitrary thing that resembles it even less because it was traded away counterfactually to another part of tegmark-5”