The quickest way to make me start viewing a scifi *topia as a dystopia is to have suicide banned in a world of (potential) immortals. To me the “right to death” is an essential once immortality is possible.
Still, I get the impression that saying they’ll die at some point anyway is a bit of a dodge of the challenge.
After all, nothing is truly infinite. Eventually entropy will necessitate an end to any simulated hell.
A suicide ban in a world of immortals is an extreme case of a policy of force-feeding hunger striking prisoners. The latter is normal in the modern United States, so it is safe to assume that if the Age of Em begins in the United States, secure deletion of an Em would likely be difficult, and abetting it, especially for prisoners, may be illegal.
I assert that the addition of potential immortality, and abandonment of ‘human scale’ times for brains built to care about human timescales creates a special case. Furthermore, a living human has, by virtue of the frailty of the human body, limits on the amount of suffering it can endure. An Em does not, so preventing an Em, or potential Em from being trapped in a torture-sim and tossed into the event horizon of a black hole to wait out the heat death of the universe is preventing something that is simply a different class of harm than the privations humans endure today.
The quickest way to make me start viewing a scifi *topia as a dystopia is to have suicide banned in a world of (potential) immortals. To me the “right to death” is an essential once immortality is possible.
Still, I get the impression that saying they’ll die at some point anyway is a bit of a dodge of the challenge. After all, nothing is truly infinite. Eventually entropy will necessitate an end to any simulated hell.
A suicide ban in a world of immortals is an extreme case of a policy of force-feeding hunger striking prisoners. The latter is normal in the modern United States, so it is safe to assume that if the Age of Em begins in the United States, secure deletion of an Em would likely be difficult, and abetting it, especially for prisoners, may be illegal.
I assert that the addition of potential immortality, and abandonment of ‘human scale’ times for brains built to care about human timescales creates a special case. Furthermore, a living human has, by virtue of the frailty of the human body, limits on the amount of suffering it can endure. An Em does not, so preventing an Em, or potential Em from being trapped in a torture-sim and tossed into the event horizon of a black hole to wait out the heat death of the universe is preventing something that is simply a different class of harm than the privations humans endure today.