Eliezer, you have in mind a quite radical vision, of creating a provably friendly God to rule us all. For you even to be able to attempt this goal requires a scenario that satisfies some assumptions many of us doubt, and even if those assumptions go your way you admit it will still be extremely hard to achieve your plan. I thus think it quite reasonable to consider other possible scenarios and plans.
Eliezer, you have in mind a quite radical vision, of creating a provably friendly God to rule us all. For you even to be able to attempt this goal requires a scenario that satisfies some assumptions many of us doubt, and even if those assumptions go your way you admit it will still be extremely hard to achieve your plan. I thus think it quite reasonable to consider other possible scenarios and plans.