In that case I am misunderstanding Wei Dai’s point. He says that complexity considerations alone can’t tell you that probability is small, because complexity appears in the numerator and the denominator. I will need to see more math (which I guess cousin it is taking care of) before understanding and agreeing with this point. But even granting it I don’t see how it implies that P(many believe H)/P(H) is for all H less than one billion.
Wei Dai did, and I defended it by referencing his position.
In that case I am misunderstanding Wei Dai’s point. He says that complexity considerations alone can’t tell you that probability is small, because complexity appears in the numerator and the denominator. I will need to see more math (which I guess cousin it is taking care of) before understanding and agreeing with this point. But even granting it I don’t see how it implies that P(many believe H)/P(H) is for all H less than one billion.