The critique-author commits to writing a response post 2-4 weeks later responding to the comments, or alternatively a response post 1-2 months later responding to all posts on LW with >20 karma that critique the initial post.
This seems much more specific than I was aiming for at this stage. That’s certainly one way to operationalize it, but I’m much more worried about the binary condition of “they expect to have to update or defend the critique at some point after people have responded to it, in some fashion, at all”, than any particular operationalization.
(edit: in fact, I think it is more important that they expect to have skin in the game 2 years later than whether they respond 2 weeks later)
I might slightly alter to one of
This seems much more specific than I was aiming for at this stage. That’s certainly one way to operationalize it, but I’m much more worried about the binary condition of “they expect to have to update or defend the critique at some point after people have responded to it, in some fashion, at all”, than any particular operationalization.
(edit: in fact, I think it is more important that they expect to have skin in the game 2 years later than whether they respond 2 weeks later)