You trust GiveWell’s judgement on which charities are the best choices
You think they’ve done enough work to establish this, at least for the time being
You don’t plan to give more money in the immediate future
Therefore, you want your money go to to the charities, not to a decision-making process that you now see as having diminishing returns
I’m not sure I’d buy it myself… it seems like it really only makes sense if you don’t think anybody else is going to be giving money to GiveWell in the immediate future either (or perhaps ever?).
You could also just think that GiveWell doesn’t currently have as much room for more funding as the recommended charities do, even though GiveWell may disagree with that assessment.
Maybe this would be a coherent position:
You trust GiveWell’s judgement on which charities are the best choices
You think they’ve done enough work to establish this, at least for the time being
You don’t plan to give more money in the immediate future
Therefore, you want your money go to to the charities, not to a decision-making process that you now see as having diminishing returns
I’m not sure I’d buy it myself… it seems like it really only makes sense if you don’t think anybody else is going to be giving money to GiveWell in the immediate future either (or perhaps ever?).
You could also just think that GiveWell doesn’t currently have as much room for more funding as the recommended charities do, even though GiveWell may disagree with that assessment.