I am sceptical about the role of alcohol you describe and dynamics around it as a form of lie detector, but I know there’s a range of social dynamics I haven’t necessarily been exposed to in my culture.
I have been in various groups that heavily drink on occasion, but I’ve never seen any evidence of people being viewed as having something to hide were they not to drink.
I think alcohol might make people more honest but I think it’s usually things they already wanted to divulge but for lack of some courage or sense of emotional intimacy that alcohol can provide. It’s hard for me to imagine alcohol playing a similar role as a lie detector for significant factual information people strongly want to hide.
Could you offer any examples of where a real lie detector would be valuable in friendships or potential friendships?
A lot of the things I might want to know seem challenging to address via a lie detector. “Will you do anything violent or steal or intentionally damage my property,”
People likely to do those things might honestly intend not to.
I could see it potentially being useful for people having sex more on the casual side.
I am sceptical about the role of alcohol you describe and dynamics around it as a form of lie detector, but I know there’s a range of social dynamics I haven’t necessarily been exposed to in my culture.
I have been in various groups that heavily drink on occasion, but I’ve never seen any evidence of people being viewed as having something to hide were they not to drink.
I think alcohol might make people more honest but I think it’s usually things they already wanted to divulge but for lack of some courage or sense of emotional intimacy that alcohol can provide. It’s hard for me to imagine alcohol playing a similar role as a lie detector for significant factual information people strongly want to hide.
Could you offer any examples of where a real lie detector would be valuable in friendships or potential friendships?
A lot of the things I might want to know seem challenging to address via a lie detector. “Will you do anything violent or steal or intentionally damage my property,” People likely to do those things might honestly intend not to.
I could see it potentially being useful for people having sex more on the casual side.