The overwhelming majority of LW users appear to agree that the post was in fact useful and high quality.
I object to this statement. The current karma of that post is as well explained by people reading this post trusting JGWeissman and hastily upvoting that post to compensate for the community’s “unfriendliness to allies”. Given that it once stood at −7, this is at least as plausible theory as yours.
(I wouldn’t object if you have omitted the word “overwhelming”, though.)
I object to this statement. The current karma of that post is as well explained by people reading this post trusting JGWeissman and hastily upvoting that post to compensate for the community’s “unfriendliness to allies”. Given that it once stood at −7, this is at least as plausible theory as yours.
(I wouldn’t object if you have omitted the word “overwhelming”, though.)