Judging by the popularity of Alicorn’s comment testifying that she “[doesn’t] think [she has] ever read a Said comment and thought it was a waste of time, or personally bothersome to [her], or sneaky or pushy or anything” (at 72 karma in 43 votes, currently the second-highest rated comment on this post), I’d bet a lot of other users feel similarly. From your stated plans, it looks like you’re not taking those 43 users’ preferences into account.
Stipulating that votes on this comment are more than negligibly informative on this question… it seems bizarre to count karma rather than agreement votes (currently 51 agreement from 37 votes). But also anyone who downvoted (or disagreed) here is someone who you’re counting as not being taken into account, which seems exactly backwards.
Stipulating that votes on this comment are more than negligibly informative on this question… it seems bizarre to count karma rather than agreement votes (currently 51 agreement from 37 votes). But also anyone who downvoted (or disagreed) here is someone who you’re counting as not being taken into account, which seems exactly backwards.