My comment wasn’t well written, I shouldn’t have used the word “complaining” in reference to what Said was doing. To clarify:
As I see it, there are two separate claims:
That the complaints prove that Said has misbehaved (at least a little bit)
That the complaints increase the probability that Said has misbehaved
Said was just asking questions—but baked into his questions is the idea of the significance of the complaints, and this significance seems to be tied to claim 1.
Jefftk seems to be speaking about claim 2. So, his comment doesn’t seem like a direct response to Said’s comment, although the point is still a relevant one.
My comment wasn’t well written, I shouldn’t have used the word “complaining” in reference to what Said was doing. To clarify:
As I see it, there are two separate claims:
That the complaints prove that Said has misbehaved (at least a little bit)
That the complaints increase the probability that Said has misbehaved
Said was just asking questions—but baked into his questions is the idea of the significance of the complaints, and this significance seems to be tied to claim 1.
Jefftk seems to be speaking about claim 2. So, his comment doesn’t seem like a direct response to Said’s comment, although the point is still a relevant one.