Designers can well design things more complicated than they are.
Agreed. Also, there is a continuum from pure evolution (with no foresight at all) to evaluation of potential designs with varying degrees of sophistication before fabricating them. (I know that I’m recalling this from a post somewhere on this site—please excuse the absence of proper credit assignment.) An example of a dumb process which is marginally smarter than evolution is to take mutation plus recombination and then do a simple gradient search to the nearest local optimum before evaluating the design.
Also, there is a continuum from pure evolution (with no foresight at all) to evaluation of potential designs with varying degrees of sophistication before fabricating them.
I’ll add that evolution with DNA and sexual reproduction already in place fits on a different part of this continuum from evolution of the simplest replicators.
Designers can guide evolution but it is still evolution that creates novelty.
Whatever intelligence is, it can’t be intelligent all the way down. It’s just dumb stuff at the bottom. — Andy Clark
Intelligence is a process facilitated by evolution. Even an AGI making perfect use of some of our most novel algorithms wouldn’t come up with something novel without evolution. See Bayesian Methods and Universal Darwinism.
Agreed. Also, there is a continuum from pure evolution (with no foresight at all) to evaluation of potential designs with varying degrees of sophistication before fabricating them. (I know that I’m recalling this from a post somewhere on this site—please excuse the absence of proper credit assignment.) An example of a dumb process which is marginally smarter than evolution is to take mutation plus recombination and then do a simple gradient search to the nearest local optimum before evaluating the design.
I’ll add that evolution with DNA and sexual reproduction already in place fits on a different part of this continuum from evolution of the simplest replicators.
Designers can guide evolution but it is still evolution that creates novelty.
Intelligence is a process facilitated by evolution. Even an AGI making perfect use of some of our most novel algorithms wouldn’t come up with something novel without evolution. See Bayesian Methods and Universal Darwinism.