Your (a) / (b) division basically makes sense to me.[*] I think we’re already at the point where we need this fracturing.
However, I don’t think that the LW format makes sense for (a). I’d probably prefer curated aggregation of good content for (a), with fairly clear lines about what’s in or out. It’s very unclear what the threshold for keeping up on LW should be.
Also, I quite like the idea of the topical centres being hosted in the same place as the core, so that they’re easy to find.
[*] A possible caveat is dealing with new community members nicely; I haven’t thought about this enough so I’m just dropping a flag here.
I quite like the idea of the topical centres being hosted in the same place as the core, so that they’re easy to find.
Also it makes it easy for mods to enforce the distinction. Instead of “I think this post and discussion is not suited for this place, could you delete it and take it elsewhere?” it can just be “This should actually be over in sub-forum X, so I’ve moved it there.”
Your (a) / (b) division basically makes sense to me.[*] I think we’re already at the point where we need this fracturing.
However, I don’t think that the LW format makes sense for (a). I’d probably prefer curated aggregation of good content for (a), with fairly clear lines about what’s in or out. It’s very unclear what the threshold for keeping up on LW should be.
Also, I quite like the idea of the topical centres being hosted in the same place as the core, so that they’re easy to find.
[*] A possible caveat is dealing with new community members nicely; I haven’t thought about this enough so I’m just dropping a flag here.
Also it makes it easy for mods to enforce the distinction. Instead of “I think this post and discussion is not suited for this place, could you delete it and take it elsewhere?” it can just be “This should actually be over in sub-forum X, so I’ve moved it there.”