In this case that abstraction is not present at the level of the rock, but only at the level of the system that uses the look-up table
What is the “system that uses the look-up table”? Do you require a particular kind of physical system in order for consciousness to exist? If not, what if the “system” which replays the sequence is a human with a pen and paper? Does the system truly exhibit the original consciousness sequence, in addition to the human’s existing consciousness?
The system that replays the sequence can be anything, including a
human with pen and paper.
Does the system truly exhibit the original consciousness sequence,
in addition to the human’s existing consciousness?
Yes, assuming that the measured consciousness sequence captured the
essential elements of the original consciousness.
To “see” the original consciousness in this system you must adopt the
correct context; the context that resolves the consciousness
abstraction within the system. From that context you will not see
the human. If you see a human following instructions and making notes,
you will not see the consciousness he is generating.
Consider a chess program playing a game against itself. If we glance
at the monitor we would see the game as it progresses. If instead we
only could examine the quarks that make up the computer, we would be
completely blind to the chess program abstraction.
What is the “system that uses the look-up table”? Do you require a particular kind of physical system in order for consciousness to exist? If not, what if the “system” which replays the sequence is a human with a pen and paper? Does the system truly exhibit the original consciousness sequence, in addition to the human’s existing consciousness?
Ah, Chinese room questions.
The system that replays the sequence can be anything, including a human with pen and paper.
Yes, assuming that the measured consciousness sequence captured the essential elements of the original consciousness.
To “see” the original consciousness in this system you must adopt the correct context; the context that resolves the consciousness abstraction within the system. From that context you will not see the human. If you see a human following instructions and making notes, you will not see the consciousness he is generating.
Consider a chess program playing a game against itself. If we glance at the monitor we would see the game as it progresses. If instead we only could examine the quarks that make up the computer, we would be completely blind to the chess program abstraction.