Signaling is a factor, but there is another issue. That is the choice of what to work on. Academics and academic departments, no less than individuals, have to make choices of where to focus their time and resources—no one has unlimited time and attention and choices have to be made. So one person, or school, may focus on cognitive biases and skimp on memory biases, or the other way around. This choice of what is important is actually very strongly affected by signaling issues—much more so than signaling affects particular beliefs, I think.
Hmmm. If I understood correctly Alicorn was talking more about the situation where people are talking/working on the same thing and still have different beliefs.
This excuses having different maps in the sense that my map may be very blurry in the areas in which I don’t work. On the other hand, I don’t think it at all excuses incompatible maps.
It doesn’t excuse them, but it does explain them—since each still has the default, evolved/social map in the unexplored areas. And they will have until the new knowledge penetrates enough to become the newer default, at least among academics.
Signaling is a factor, but there is another issue. That is the choice of what to work on. Academics and academic departments, no less than individuals, have to make choices of where to focus their time and resources—no one has unlimited time and attention and choices have to be made. So one person, or school, may focus on cognitive biases and skimp on memory biases, or the other way around. This choice of what is important is actually very strongly affected by signaling issues—much more so than signaling affects particular beliefs, I think.
Hmmm. If I understood correctly Alicorn was talking more about the situation where people are talking/working on the same thing and still have different beliefs.
This excuses having different maps in the sense that my map may be very blurry in the areas in which I don’t work. On the other hand, I don’t think it at all excuses incompatible maps.
It doesn’t excuse them, but it does explain them—since each still has the default, evolved/social map in the unexplored areas. And they will have until the new knowledge penetrates enough to become the newer default, at least among academics.