I can point to rebuttals, but “comprehensive rebuttal” suggests you want me to address every argument for Foom. If you already know of a bunch of existing resources, probably it would be easier for you to mention at least one anti-Foom argument you find persuasive, or at least one hole in a pro-Foom argument that you find important, etc.
Then I won’t waste time addressing 9⁄10 of the well-trod arguments only to find that the remaining 1⁄10 I left out of my uncomprehensive rebuttal was the part you actually cared about and found credible. :P
(Also, I’m not necessarily committing to writing a detailed reply. If I don’t follow up, feel free to update some that I plausibly either don’t have a good response on hand, or don’t have an easy/concise response, taking into account that I’m juggling a lot of other things at the moment. I’m primarily commenting here because I’m interested in promoting more object-level discussion of topics like this in general; and maybe someone else will reply even if I don’t.)
I can point to rebuttals, but “comprehensive rebuttal” suggests you want me to address every argument for Foom. If you already know of a bunch of existing resources, probably it would be easier for you to mention at least one anti-Foom argument you find persuasive, or at least one hole in a pro-Foom argument that you find important, etc.
Then I won’t waste time addressing 9⁄10 of the well-trod arguments only to find that the remaining 1⁄10 I left out of my uncomprehensive rebuttal was the part you actually cared about and found credible. :P
(Also, I’m not necessarily committing to writing a detailed reply. If I don’t follow up, feel free to update some that I plausibly either don’t have a good response on hand, or don’t have an easy/concise response, taking into account that I’m juggling a lot of other things at the moment. I’m primarily commenting here because I’m interested in promoting more object-level discussion of topics like this in general; and maybe someone else will reply even if I don’t.)
If you mean address every argument against foom, then yes.
If a comprehensive rebuttal doesn’t already exist, and you have to write it now, that suggests it’s not anywhere close to agreed upon.
In any case I find Robin Hanson’s argument credible. I’ve not yet seen a persuasive rebuttal so if you can find one I’d be impressed.