I didn’t use the word “ethics” in my comment, so are you making a definitional statement, to distinguish between [universal value system] and [subjective value system] or just authoritatively saying that I’m wrong?
Are you claiming moral realism? I don’t really believe that. If “ethics” is global, why should I care about “ethics”? Sorry if that sounds callous, I do actually care about the world, just trying to pin down what you mean.
Yeah definitional. I think “I should do x” means about the same as “It’s ethical to do x”. In the latter the indexical “I” has disappeared, indicating that it’s a global statement, not a local one, objective rather than subjective. But “I care about doing x” is local/subjective because it doesn’t contain words like “should”, “ethical”, or “moral patienthood”.
I didn’t use the word “ethics” in my comment, so are you making a definitional statement, to distinguish between [universal value system] and [subjective value system] or just authoritatively saying that I’m wrong?
Are you claiming moral realism? I don’t really believe that. If “ethics” is global, why should I care about “ethics”? Sorry if that sounds callous, I do actually care about the world, just trying to pin down what you mean.
Yeah definitional. I think “I should do x” means about the same as “It’s ethical to do x”. In the latter the indexical “I” has disappeared, indicating that it’s a global statement, not a local one, objective rather than subjective. But “I care about doing x” is local/subjective because it doesn’t contain words like “should”, “ethical”, or “moral patienthood”.