POLL: Should discussion take place on the original post (with people leaving comments to Eliezer’s post) or on the new post (leaving comments to post in the discussion section which links to Eliezer’s post)? Vote here: original post new post karma balance
I disagreed, but I would reverse my vote if there were also a way for the old, original posts to link visibly to their corresponding new discussions. (Not just in a tacked-on comment at the bottom.)
I’m surprised you don’t have the power to do that yourself. I think it would be helpful if there were a few people with such superpowers, but I don’t know if the Reddit codebase supports it.
POLL: Should discussion take place on the original post (with people leaving comments to Eliezer’s post) or on the new post (leaving comments to post in the discussion section which links to Eliezer’s post)? Vote here:
original post
new post
karma balance
Vote up to have discussion on the new post.
Vote up to have discussion on the original post.
And here’s somewhere to collect discussion of this question so people can find the poll options!
Strongly favour having discussion on the new post—I think “re-booting” the discussions is one of the biggest benefits of this proposal.
I disagreed, but I would reverse my vote if there were also a way for the old, original posts to link visibly to their corresponding new discussions. (Not just in a tacked-on comment at the bottom.)
I’m surprised you don’t have the power to do that yourself. I think it would be helpful if there were a few people with such superpowers, but I don’t know if the Reddit codebase supports it.
That seems to be the difference between a moderator and an editor. I’m only the first thing.
Vote down for karma balance.