We look at game theory in different ways. By my analysis it is irrelevant what Player 2 would get if A were played, it could be $1 trillion or -$1 trillion and it would have no impact on the game as I see it. But then I don’t use timeless decision theory, and you might be. This could be the source of our disagreement.
No, I’m just saying that since in your particular example Player 2 is indifferent when Player 1 chooses A, the fact that they don’t get a decision doesn’t matter. Nothing to do with TDT.
We look at game theory in different ways. By my analysis it is irrelevant what Player 2 would get if A were played, it could be $1 trillion or -$1 trillion and it would have no impact on the game as I see it. But then I don’t use timeless decision theory, and you might be. This could be the source of our disagreement.
No, I’m just saying that since in your particular example Player 2 is indifferent when Player 1 chooses A, the fact that they don’t get a decision doesn’t matter. Nothing to do with TDT.