He says things like AlphaGo or GPT-3 being really surprising to gradualists, suggesting he thinks that gradualism only works in hindsight.
I agree that after shaking out the other disagreements, we could just end up with Eliezer saying “yeah but automating AI R&D is just fundamentally unlike all the other tasks to which we’ve applied AI” (or “AI improving AI will be fundamentally unlike automating humans improving AI”) but I don’t think that’s the core of his position right now.
He says things like AlphaGo or GPT-3 being really surprising to gradualists, suggesting he thinks that gradualism only works in hindsight.
I agree that after shaking out the other disagreements, we could just end up with Eliezer saying “yeah but automating AI R&D is just fundamentally unlike all the other tasks to which we’ve applied AI” (or “AI improving AI will be fundamentally unlike automating humans improving AI”) but I don’t think that’s the core of his position right now.