Pyramid: The point is that sure, that’s possible, but we shouldn’t bet on that. That is, if we do discover psi is real, without having discovered a reduction for it, then we should increase our belief that the universe has irreducible mental (or mental like) components.
It is not absolute proof. The point is that it actually would be evidence favoring that position. It’s not quite obvious to me that it would be strong evidence, but the argument does seem convincing that it would be evidence.
Pyramid: The point is that sure, that’s possible, but we shouldn’t bet on that. That is, if we do discover psi is real, without having discovered a reduction for it, then we should increase our belief that the universe has irreducible mental (or mental like) components.
It is not absolute proof. The point is that it actually would be evidence favoring that position. It’s not quite obvious to me that it would be strong evidence, but the argument does seem convincing that it would be evidence.