so that we aren’t confused when we go from one document to another
Why, on your view, would going from using “he” to refer to a hypothetical person in one document, to using “she” to refer to a different hypothetical person in a different document, be confusing?
(Not, mind you, that I intend to do this. I’ve been using the gender-neutral third-person plural pronoun consistently in these situations for years and see no reason to stop. )
Hypothetical people, or people of unknown gender, have no gender in reality I can refer to. If I have to treat them as gendered anyway, surely it is easier to have a default gender to fall back on, rather than having to keep track of the particular nonce gender of this particular hypothetical person/person of unknown gender.
For my part, if I’m being told a story about an actual person, whom I don’t know, who is referred to as “him” or “her,” I don’t find it especially confusing to subsequently keep track of their gender.
Nor do I find it significantly more confusing if they are hypothetical instead of actual.
I hadn’t previously realized there were people who differed from me in that regard. That’s useful to know: thanks for clarifying.
Why, on your view, would going from using “he” to refer to a hypothetical person in one document, to using “she” to refer to a different hypothetical person in a different document, be confusing?
(Not, mind you, that I intend to do this. I’ve been using the gender-neutral third-person plural pronoun consistently in these situations for years and see no reason to stop. )
Hypothetical people, or people of unknown gender, have no gender in reality I can refer to. If I have to treat them as gendered anyway, surely it is easier to have a default gender to fall back on, rather than having to keep track of the particular nonce gender of this particular hypothetical person/person of unknown gender.
Interesting.
For my part, if I’m being told a story about an actual person, whom I don’t know, who is referred to as “him” or “her,” I don’t find it especially confusing to subsequently keep track of their gender.
Nor do I find it significantly more confusing if they are hypothetical instead of actual.
I hadn’t previously realized there were people who differed from me in that regard. That’s useful to know: thanks for clarifying.