Question: If the world were wiped out tomorrow leaving a few people and you were the only survivor with any minimal scientific training, could you on your own reconstruct special relativity? If the answer to this is “no” then you don’t understand it.
Note that by this standard I don’t understand QM and I really don’t understand GR and I’m a math grad student. It is ok to say that one doesn’t understand things.
Question: If the world were wiped out tomorrow leaving a few people and you were the only survivor with any minimal scientific training, could you on your own reconstruct special relativity? If the answer to this is “no” then you don’t understand it.
Yes. I already declared this, in a comment you replied to no less.
Additional claim: It has been too long since I studied physics for me to remember all of the mathematics of special relativity. Yet when I did the aforementioned study I also gained a solid grasp of the fundamental principles. With that understanding I could recreate the interesting mathematics from first principles. I am confident of this because I’ve done it before, just for kicks. Because memorizing the math wasn’t enough for me and I wanted to really grasp the science in depth. The way you do that is by knowing the concepts well enough that you could work out the equations for yourself. Because just memorizing them is detail work. (I haven’t got a chance in hell of doing this with GR.)
Question: If the world were wiped out tomorrow leaving a few people and you were the only survivor with any minimal scientific training, could you on your own reconstruct special relativity? If the answer to this is “no” then you don’t understand it.
Note that by this standard I don’t understand QM and I really don’t understand GR and I’m a math grad student. It is ok to say that one doesn’t understand things.
Yes. I already declared this, in a comment you replied to no less.