Then don’t define magic as ‘that which disturbs the map-territory distinction’, but rather ‘awfully (in)convenient physics’. The map-territory distinction still works. Just, fundamental physics is much, much harder to work out there.
But mental things are already part of the terrain. Our minds are implemented in matter.
If physics happens to notice any mental activity and react to it, then that’s weird physics—REALLY weird—but it’s not like it’s suddenly impossible to conceptualize a thing without that thing being instantiated, and it’s really really possible to discover that you were wrong about a thing.
Except it absolutely does not feel so from the inside, which is precisely the issue. Mental things are internal map-representations. For example how a dark forest feels threatening or a storm viciously raging.
Then don’t define magic as ‘that which disturbs the map-territory distinction’, but rather ‘awfully (in)convenient physics’. The map-territory distinction still works. Just, fundamental physics is much, much harder to work out there.
No, I don’t think it is the case. They take mental things and make the part of the terrain. It is not just paranormal physics.
But mental things are already part of the terrain. Our minds are implemented in matter.
If physics happens to notice any mental activity and react to it, then that’s weird physics—REALLY weird—but it’s not like it’s suddenly impossible to conceptualize a thing without that thing being instantiated, and it’s really really possible to discover that you were wrong about a thing.
Except it absolutely does not feel so from the inside, which is precisely the issue. Mental things are internal map-representations. For example how a dark forest feels threatening or a storm viciously raging.