Shapley values are constructed such that introducing a null player doesn’t change the result. You are doing something different by considering the wrong counterfactual (one where C exists but isn’t part of the coalition, vs one when it doesn’t exist)
Sounds like you agree with both me and Ninety-Three about the descriptive claim that the Shapley Value has, in fact, been changed, and have not yet expressed any position regarding the normative claim that this is a problem?
Shapley values are constructed such that introducing a null player doesn’t change the result. You are doing something different by considering the wrong counterfactual (one where C exists but isn’t part of the coalition, vs one when it doesn’t exist)
Sounds like you agree with both me and Ninety-Three about the descriptive claim that the Shapley Value has, in fact, been changed, and have not yet expressed any position regarding the normative claim that this is a problem?