I’m still interested in this question. I don’t think you really did what I asked—it seems like you were thinking ‘how can I convince him that this is impossible’ not ‘how can I find a way to build a dyson swarm.’ I’m interested in both but was hoping to have someone with more engineering and physics background than me take a stab at the latter.
My current understanding of the situation is: There’s no reason why we can’t concentrate enough energy on the surface of Mercury, given enough orbiting solar panels and lasers; the problem instead seems to be that we need to avoid melting all the equipment on the surface. Or, in other words, the maximum amount of material we can launch off Mercury per second is limited by the maximum amount of heat that can be radiated outwards from Mercury (for a given operating temperature of the local equipment?) And you are claiming that this amount of heat radiation ability, for radiators only the size of Mercury’s surface, is OOMs too small to enable dyson swarm construction. Is this right?
I’m still interested in this question. I don’t think you really did what I asked—it seems like you were thinking ‘how can I convince him that this is impossible’ not ‘how can I find a way to build a dyson swarm.’ I’m interested in both but was hoping to have someone with more engineering and physics background than me take a stab at the latter.
My current understanding of the situation is: There’s no reason why we can’t concentrate enough energy on the surface of Mercury, given enough orbiting solar panels and lasers; the problem instead seems to be that we need to avoid melting all the equipment on the surface. Or, in other words, the maximum amount of material we can launch off Mercury per second is limited by the maximum amount of heat that can be radiated outwards from Mercury (for a given operating temperature of the local equipment?) And you are claiming that this amount of heat radiation ability, for radiators only the size of Mercury’s surface, is OOMs too small to enable dyson swarm construction. Is this right?