Vladimir, I should have looked more carefully before replying to this comment the first time. Because Eliezer actually said:
And it’s logical possibility of the Zombie World, not conceptual possibility, that is needed to suppose that a logically omniscient mind [my italics] could know the positions of all the atoms in the universe, and yet need to be told as an additional non-entailed fact that we have inner listeners.
So it is in fact plainly untrue that “Yudkowsky doesn’t include omniscient beings in his argument”. That is explicitly the context of the discussion.
Vladimir, I should have looked more carefully before replying to this comment the first time. Because Eliezer actually said:
So it is in fact plainly untrue that “Yudkowsky doesn’t include omniscient beings in his argument”. That is explicitly the context of the discussion.