Well, there’s also the matter of why I’d think he’s nuts when facing “either he’s a supergenius or he’s nuts” dilemma created by overly high confidence expressed in overly speculative arguments. But yea I’m not sure it’s getting anywhere, the target audience is just EY himself, and I do expect he’d read this at least out of curiosity to see how he’s being defended, but with low confidence so I’m done.
If your purpose is “let everyone know I think Eliezer is nuts”, then you have succeeded, and may cease posting.
Well, there’s also the matter of why I’d think he’s nuts when facing “either he’s a supergenius or he’s nuts” dilemma created by overly high confidence expressed in overly speculative arguments. But yea I’m not sure it’s getting anywhere, the target audience is just EY himself, and I do expect he’d read this at least out of curiosity to see how he’s being defended, but with low confidence so I’m done.