So: do you really think that humans wouldn’t find a martian civilization interesting? Surely there would be many humans who would be incredibly interested.
I find Jupiter interesting. I think a paperclip maximizer (choosing a different intuition pump for the same point) could be more interesting than Jupiter, but it would generate an astronomically tiny fraction of the total potential for interestingness in this universe.
Life isn’t much of an “interestingness” maximiser. Expecting to produce more than a tiny fraction of the total potential for interestingness in this universe seems as though it would be rather unreasonable.
I agree that a paperclip maximiser would be more boring than an ordinary entropy-maximising civilization—though I don’t know by how much—probably not by a huge amount—the basic problems it faces are much the same—the paperclip maximiser just has fewer atoms to work with.
So: do you really think that humans wouldn’t find a martian civilization interesting? Surely there would be many humans who would be incredibly interested.
I find Jupiter interesting. I think a paperclip maximizer (choosing a different intuition pump for the same point) could be more interesting than Jupiter, but it would generate an astronomically tiny fraction of the total potential for interestingness in this universe.
Life isn’t much of an “interestingness” maximiser. Expecting to produce more than a tiny fraction of the total potential for interestingness in this universe seems as though it would be rather unreasonable.
I agree that a paperclip maximiser would be more boring than an ordinary entropy-maximising civilization—though I don’t know by how much—probably not by a huge amount—the basic problems it faces are much the same—the paperclip maximiser just has fewer atoms to work with.