I agree this movie will have an impact. My guess it will be polarizing, which is not the worst thing—right now the area of AI risk suffers from lack of attention more than from a specific opposing opinions. Having these themes enter public memesphere, even through entertainment, seems useful.
As far as MIRI commenting on it I think it’s too early and would seem to an intelligent observer as jumping on the bandwagon attention whoring—the movie is not even out yet. I imagine after the release there will be a flurry of PopSci type of articles, at which point weighing it might be appropriate and well received.
In what alternate reality? Every prominent politician, and every substantial business or other organisation, has people whose whole job is what you scorn as “attention whoring”. It’s more usually called something like “publicity”, “press department”, or “outreach”, and I hope MIRI spends a significant number of man-hours on it. Telling people about yourself is a fundamental prerequisite for people knowing about you and whatever cause or business purpose you are trying to pursue. (There are ways of doing this badly, but the surest way of doing it badly is to be resentful at having to do it at all.)
So, MIRI needs to have more than just a comment ready. They need to be able to supply anyone who asks with a whole position paper relating to the film, and where relevant, work references to it into their publicity material, at such time as the actual content of the movie becomes clear. (And there are ways of doing this badly, but etc.)
The journalist might never come knocking, but when opportunity knocks, it is too late to prepare for it. Not doing this for fear of “attention whoring” and people thinking them “low status” would be shooting themselves in the foot. And why would that journalist come knocking? Because the publicity department of the production company has been publicising the film months in advance, and because MIRI has made itself prominent enough to be known to at least one journalist as having something to say on the subject.
I agree with you that it’s important to be prepared; the attention whoring referred specifically to commenting on the movie before it comes out, and it’s plot and “statement” (if there is one) becomes clear.
I agree it would be early to comment now, but much gets written during the marketing run-up to release. By that time, not only after release, an easily findable comment can make a lot of impact. Compare how Wikileaks’ comments on “The Fifth Estate”, published before the release, influenced what got written about that movie.
And whoever writes something pre-release will be findable when people look for somebody to weigh in post-release.
Well one idea is write something on your blog and link it to MIRI; PageRank will do the rest :)
Another idea—organize a public movie event with a panel afterwards. Should attract a significant sci-fi fan interest and maybe get some coverage (maybe even use it as a fundraiser?). Louie Helm did this for “Our Final Invention”. Will ping him.
Are you sure being a polarized subject would be much better than suffering from lack of attention? At least now, MIRI and others are able to work in relative peace.
I agree this movie will have an impact. My guess it will be polarizing, which is not the worst thing—right now the area of AI risk suffers from lack of attention more than from a specific opposing opinions. Having these themes enter public memesphere, even through entertainment, seems useful.
As far as MIRI commenting on it I think it’s too early and would seem to an intelligent observer as jumping on the bandwagon attention whoring—the movie is not even out yet. I imagine after the release there will be a flurry of PopSci type of articles, at which point weighing it might be appropriate and well received.
You say that like its a bad thing.
That has to be prepared for (in advance—that is what preparation is). If a journalist asks MIRI for comment, they need to have a comment ready.
Status wise it’s a bad thing.
In what alternate reality? Every prominent politician, and every substantial business or other organisation, has people whose whole job is what you scorn as “attention whoring”. It’s more usually called something like “publicity”, “press department”, or “outreach”, and I hope MIRI spends a significant number of man-hours on it. Telling people about yourself is a fundamental prerequisite for people knowing about you and whatever cause or business purpose you are trying to pursue. (There are ways of doing this badly, but the surest way of doing it badly is to be resentful at having to do it at all.)
So, MIRI needs to have more than just a comment ready. They need to be able to supply anyone who asks with a whole position paper relating to the film, and where relevant, work references to it into their publicity material, at such time as the actual content of the movie becomes clear. (And there are ways of doing this badly, but etc.)
The journalist might never come knocking, but when opportunity knocks, it is too late to prepare for it. Not doing this for fear of “attention whoring” and people thinking them “low status” would be shooting themselves in the foot. And why would that journalist come knocking? Because the publicity department of the production company has been publicising the film months in advance, and because MIRI has made itself prominent enough to be known to at least one journalist as having something to say on the subject.
I agree with you that it’s important to be prepared; the attention whoring referred specifically to commenting on the movie before it comes out, and it’s plot and “statement” (if there is one) becomes clear.
What’s the solution to that? Does MIRI need an attention-whoring low-status little sister?
Isn’t that called “the PR arm?”
Ha! Me and my sister always say that! I think it was her canonical answer to “You always have an answer, don’t you?”
I agree it would be early to comment now, but much gets written during the marketing run-up to release. By that time, not only after release, an easily findable comment can make a lot of impact. Compare how Wikileaks’ comments on “The Fifth Estate”, published before the release, influenced what got written about that movie.
And whoever writes something pre-release will be findable when people look for somebody to weigh in post-release.
Well one idea is write something on your blog and link it to MIRI; PageRank will do the rest :)
Another idea—organize a public movie event with a panel afterwards. Should attract a significant sci-fi fan interest and maybe get some coverage (maybe even use it as a fundraiser?). Louie Helm did this for “Our Final Invention”. Will ping him.
The panel idea—especially if this can be done early, has a lot of value, could boost discussion and also provide a possible influx here.
Are you sure being a polarized subject would be much better than suffering from lack of attention? At least now, MIRI and others are able to work in relative peace.