This is very interesting and seems to have potential. Thanks for pointing me to the article! The important thing though would be to see the technique in action. Is there a thread were the community is experimenting with the application of the methodology?
Specific applications of the framework that I have seen in practice were always offline discussions. Most online discussions are unstructured and people don’t follow an explicit framework.
http://lesswrong.com/lw/o6p/double_crux_a_strategy_for_resolving_disagreement/ is a well specific methodology.
This is very interesting and seems to have potential. Thanks for pointing me to the article! The important thing though would be to see the technique in action. Is there a thread were the community is experimenting with the application of the methodology?
Specific applications of the framework that I have seen in practice were always offline discussions. Most online discussions are unstructured and people don’t follow an explicit framework.
As far as structured goes, there’s http://predictionbook.com/ and http://www.metaculus.com